Sorry evil dog.
I had to give you a 1/5 for many reasons.
1. Controls, i couldent tell where the little dot was going, if it was going up, down, or any of the slants.
2. Lag, You made the game so complicated, it was lagging bad, i tried to play the game, but the lag stopped me from hitting the notes on time.
3. Not simplistic. We loved punk o matic 1 because it was simple, you could go in, pick the riffs, and your good! here, we have to change our Characters, Write tons of songs, perform them (on a crappy game engine might i add).
Please fix these problems, make a new "song play" engine, As much as i know you hate guitar hero, it seems to be an effective system, fix the lag, (do we need tons of amps in the back with a song playing? and maybe cut down a feature or two.